(Letter has been copied word for word from
President Noble's signed letter of Nov. 19th addressed to Governor Barnes.
A copy of the original letter can be obtained by contacting GAE.)
November 19, 2001
The Honorable Roy E. Barnes
Governor of Georgia
203 State Capitol
Atlanta, Georgia 30334
Dear Governor Barnes:
We are writing to urge you to take the legislative or State Board of Education initiative to solve a very big problem, which is the attraction and retention of middle school teachers in Georgia. Among the many changes made in Georgia's Middle School Program is the requirement that continued employment necessitates completion of either 50 hours of professional staff development through five credit hours of professional staff development or three college semester hours in the teaching and evaluation of reading. One of the purposes stated for this certification requirement is 'to prepare all middle grade educators to teach and evaluate reading and writing across the curriculum.' The State Board of Education policy further states, 'Middle schools are encouraged to use common planning time to deliver instruction during the teacher workday.'
The results of this policy are frustrating for our dedicated middle school teachers. Many are opting to transfer to either an elementary or high school to avoid completing yet another recertification requirement imposed upon them without their voices being heard. Some are simply leaving the teaching profession, and those with adequate service credit are retiring. The teacher shortage problem is increasing, and the ability to attract middle school teachers has been tarnished.
We urge you to correct this problem during the 2002 legislative session. Teachers in specific academic areas (i.e. ' mathematics, science, social studies, etc.) should be exempted from the requirement. We heard you state on many occasions that competency in the subject to which a teacher is assigned should be increased. Your education reform initiative limited middle school teachers to two academic subject areas, emphasized subject content knowledge, and required colleges and universities to add reading course requirements to teacher preparation graduation requirements.
The Honorable Roy E. Barnes
November 19, 2001
Page 2
Teachers in non language arts subject areas do not want to teach reading. Why should our dedicated, productive, successful middle school mathematic teachers be forced to teach one or two classes in reading instead of a full teaching load in mathematics? Good math teachers will tell you that as professionals they cannot improve student performance in reading as well as certified reading teachers. Why not require middle schools to employ reading teachers for the reading curriculum requirements instead of compelling all middle school teachers to diversify their subject area?
Many boards of education will interpret the option of using common planning time to deliver instruction during the teacher workday as a mandate to eliminate all planning time. When the common planning time was reduced by 30 minutes for middle school teachers, as a result of your legislation, GAE objected. Middle school teachers were omitted from the duty free lunch period legislation because they desired to continue the 85 minute common planning time. In addition to being assigned lunch duty, they are also expected to conduct conferences with parents and guardians, plan curriculum improvements and lessons, goals and objectives, complete voluminous paper work, perform administrative duties, work with student discipline referrals, perform other duties as assigned by the principal, and complete normal planning period tasks such as grading student assignments and personal lesson planning during their reduced planning period.
The State Board of Education policy does not recognize current middle school teachers who earned college credit in reading courses and those who have completed staff development in reading. Those credits should count toward fulfillment of this certification requirement. The policy assumes that middle school teachers with degrees in language arts curriculum areas are not qualified to teach reading. Many middle school teachers who have earned National Board Certification, master's, six year, and doctorate degrees are insulted. It is far past time for Georgia to recognize that certification standards established by the DOE and PSC and completed by educators should not be changed without a grandfather clause. Our middle school teachers who have completed in good faith the requirements outlined by the DOE and the PSC should be exempted from additional requirements.
The policy also requires new middle school teachers to complete the reading instruction within two years of service. Over 30 percent of new teachers leave our profession in the first three years of employment. This requirement only accelerates the departure rate. New teachers need to spend valuable time in a strong mentoring program that improves student achievement and professional growth.
The State Board policy acknowledges questions raised by middle school teachers with this requirement by stating, 'The Department of Education will evaluate the implementation and the effect of this initiative on the delivery of instruction and on student achievement.' Why should this evaluation not have occurred before the policy was written? If data is not available to support the positive effect on student achievement by the added emphasis on reading, why are teachers being required to complete this recertification provision before results are made available?
The Honorable Roy E. Barnes
November 19, 2001
Page 3
Teachers are being required to complete the 50 hour SDU course during planning period time, after school hours, Saturdays, and summer and semester breaks without compensation for the additional work time. Other non teaching duties and expectations have not been reduced. We cannot continue to reduce the planning time for middle school teachers, increase recertification requirements and working hours, and compel non instructional duty assignments and keep our good, talented middle school teachers.
We hope you will make the necessary legislative or State Board of Education adjustments to correct this growing problem. Our suggestions include: limiting the reading requirement to those who are directly involved in teaching reading and language arts; exempting those who have earned middle school certification or completed similar reading requirements or college credits; compensating teachers for extra work hours required by the policy; exempting non language arts teachers from the policy; and keeping the common planning time duty free.
We would appreciate your cooperation in addressing this problem.
Sincerely,
Ralph Noble, GAE President
Bob Cribbs, GAE Director of Communications
cc: Linda C. Schrenko, State Superintendent of Schools
Dr. F. D. Toth, Executive Secretary of the Professional Standards Commission
Cathy Henson, State Board of Education member
Ron Newcomb, Education Advisor to Governor Barnes