Restore Georgia's Fair Dismissal Law
GAE supports legislation to protect educators' academic, political, and personal rights by restoring and strengthening Georgia's Fair Dismissal law.
During the 2000 session of the Georgia General Assembly, the fair dismissal process for teachers employed after July 1, 2000 was eliminated. Governor Barnes stated that "good teachers do not need tenure (fair dismissal) and bad teachers do not deserve it!" GAE firmly believes that the fair dismissal procedure was adopted to protect good teachers from bad management. Therefore, GAE supports legislation to restore the fair dismissal process to all educators including teachers, administrators, and education support personnel, and to provide a procedure to appeal dismissal decisions to a neutral third party hearing examiner.
GAE believes that all educators should be provided basic due process rights in dismissal, transfer, promotion, demotion, and discipline employment decisions. All educators including administrators, teachers, and support personnel should be afforded the opportunity to hear and receive allegations of poor performance and misconduct, answer the allegations through a fair grievance procedure, and defend themselves against the allegations before a fair, impartial hearing examiner. Recommendations concerning employment decisions should be based on the best interest of students, established standards of excellence, and the school community, not arbitrary or capricious factors.
In order for the fair dismissal process to work effectively, Georgia must improve the employee evaluation process. All employee evaluations must be open, honest, fair, and based on job performance and not extraneous factors. Good evaluations enable educators to understand goals and objectives and problems which must be corrected. Fair evaluations are a necessary tool in measuring how an employee is performing his/her duties and providing assistance for improvement when needed. GAE believes that "peer review" evaluations by colleagues will lead to improved student learning, achievement, and staffing decisions. Peer review is used in California and many progressive school districts and puts accountability regarding employment performance directly on those affected by poor performance.
Perhaps the most misunderstood term concerning educator disciplinary employment decisions is "tenure." Tenure does not exist for Georgia's public school employees, or any K 12 public school employees in this country. What other states do have, and Georgia had until this past legislative session, are due process rights (fair dismissal) for public school teachers. Fair dismissal is the most important of all the rights gained by educators in the 20th century and provides recognition that the educator has proven successful in his/her profession. Fair dismissal is gained only after the educator has been thoroughly evaluated and reviewed and has met the high standards of performance established by school districts and state and national guidelines. Fair dismissal is not protection of incompetent educators from disciplinary decisions, but assurance that those recommendations are based on a fair process designed to protect educators from arbitrary and unjust decisions concerning their careers. Without fair dismissal, educators are reluctant to make school improvement suggestions to administrators or school board members and are less likely to initiate creative and innovative methods for improved student learning and job performance.
If colleagues empowered in the peer review system recommend disciplinary action against an employee, the immediate supervisor should be required to intervene by observing the employee, recommending necessary improvement, and establishing a time frame for successful completion of the improvement plan. For those educators who do not measure up to the high employment standards, disciplinary action must be based on the evaluation, and educators must be protected against all arbitrary and capricious discipline.
GAE would like to believe that all disciplinary decisions are made with regard to the best interest of the teaching profession, student learning and achievement, and advancing the high academic standards of the district. But often these decisions are based on arbitrary and capricious reasons'a parent falsely accuses the educator of misconduct, a student decides to "get even," or an administrator has a personality conflict with the educator. Many such decisions are incorrect because a policy or rule is misconstrued or misapplied, or the political interests of the school board were interrupted. The educator must have a fair appeal process and understand that the final decision regarding the adverse employment recommendation will be heard by a fair, impartial hearing officer not employed by the local board of education.
Such an impartial hearing officer process, which is utilized by most state government agencies, would be cost effective and relieve local school board members of a legal responsibility for which they are not prepared. Utilization of this fair, impartial system will greatly improve the confidence in elected officials by educators and result in improved collegiality and collaboration.