GAE Response to
Raid on TRS Retirement Funds
August 2001
TO: Members of the Georgia General Assembly
FROM: Ralph Noble, President
Bob Cribbs, Director of Communications Services
RE: TRS Employer Rate Reduction
We hope you are enjoying a safe and relaxing summer.
We are writing to express our concerns and disappointment with the decision by the Teachers Retirement System of Georgia's Board of Trustees to decrease the employer contribution rate by 2.05%. This action, which occurred only two months after you adjourned, represents the third employer contribution rate reduction in the past decade and means the rate has now been reduced by 4.05%. The rate reduction translates into the loss of about $160 million in TRS revenues. The three reductions totaled about $320 million in funding that could have been used to improve TRS benefits for Georgia's dedicated school employees, which most of you support.
While TRS decreased the employer contribution rate three times, the employee contribution rate was decreased only once and by only 1%. Added to the $320 million of lost revenues, TRS could have had about $400 million more annually which would have funded legislation to permit retirement without penalty after 25 years; the opportunity for retired teachers to return to work without penalty, thus solving part of our teacher shortage problem; an additional COLA increase for those retired; and other benefits competitive with other southern states.
You continually hear that Georgia's Teachers Retirement System is among the most fiscally sound in the nation. Although we are proud of that fact, TRS is lagging behind in benefits. A comparison of TRS benefits and employer rates with other southern states reveals, for example, that Alabama provides full retirement without penalty after 25 years of service; Arkansas after 28 years; Kentucky after 27 years; Louisiana after 20 years; Mississippi after 25 years; and South Carolina after 28 years. The employer contribution rate is 12% in Arkansas, 13.05% in Kentucky, 14.2% in Louisiana, 9.75% in Mississippi, and 15% in West Virginia.
In Georgia we have chosen to bank the investment and interest gains instead of improving member benefits. These facts are even more disappointing considering the TRS structural portfolio increased by almost $2 billion during the last year ($1,909,038,918). Why can these gains not be transferred into benefit improvements? What other retirement investment fund could realize these types of gains without improving plan benefits? TRS is acting more like a bank rather than an employee retirement program. Their message to you year after year is, 'provide us the funds and we will add the benefit.' Why can TRS not provide you with suggestions to improve the benefits by sharing in the cost? Why should TRS not advocate for member benefit improvements?
At the very least, TRS could have passed on improvements in benefits to those who have retired. For example, TRS is supporting House Bill 822 that would provide a much needed COLA increase to retirees. The Board of Trustees could have funded this benefit improvement instead of decreasing the employer contribution rate. TRS could have urged passage of legislation permitting them to decrease the employee contribution rate proportionately with the employer rate. For example, both the employer and employee rates should have been reduced equally by 2.5% during the past decade.
While members of the State Employees' Retirement System contribute only 1'%, TRS members are assessed 5%. Instead of being advocates for the members they are charged to serve, TRS is content with a growing fund that has not substantially improved benefits for 20 years. It is time to change the operational procedures of TRS and make the Trustees more accountable to members. GAE will be urging the adoption of such legislation during the 2002 session, and we hope you will support our efforts.
A brief history of TRS reveals that in 1970 the benefits included vesting after 20 years, retirement after 35 years of creditable service, disability benefits after 20 years, and a benefit ratio of 1.75%. During the next 12 years, legislators decreased the vesting and disability benefit period to 10 years (1973); increased the benefit formula to 2% (1.76% 1975, 1.78% 1976, 1.80% 1977, 1.84% ' 1978, 1.88% 1979, 1.92% 1981, and 2% 1982); and provided full retirement benefits without penalty after 30 years of creditable service (1975, after 31 years in 1974). You can understand why TRS members are so disgruntled with the Trustees for failing to become a partner in our quest to improve benefits. Remember that the legislation to permit retirement after 25 years of service has a 7% per year penalty which ranks among the highest of any state, and the ability to apply unused sick leave for retirement credit took two years to fund even though the cost was minimal.
Had we been as successful during the last 20 years with benefit improvements as we were during the 1970s, TRS members would not be as mistrustful of Trustees. We hope that Governor Barnes will recommend that funds saved from the employer rate reduction be used to add benefit improvements. Our beginning teachers are determined to have the ability to choose a portable retirement plan, like a 401K option, instead of joining TRS.
We wish you well during the redistricting process and will be discussing needed changes in the TRS in order to better meet the desires of members in adding benefit improvements. Please call on us with any questions or comments and note our new address and telephone number 100 Crescent Centre Parkway, Suite 500, Tucker, Georgia 30084 7449; telephone 678 837 1100 or toll free 1 800 282 7142; and fax 678 837 1140.
TRS Letter | Governor's Letter