Skip to content
Georgia Association of Educators
Georgia Association of Educators schoolhouse mark Georgia Association of Educators Support · Protect · Strengthen
Toll free in Georgia1 800 282 7142
Join GAE

Protest Letter to members of TRS BOD (2001)

GAE Response to Raid on TRS Retirement Funds

July 17, 2001

MEMORANDUM

TO: Members of the TRS Board of Directors

FROM: Ralph Noble, President
Bob Cribbs, Director of Communications Services

RE: Employer Rate Reduction

We are writing to express our concerns and disappointment with your unanimous decision to decrease the TRS employer contribution rate by 2.05%. This action represents the third employer contribution rate reduction in the past decade and means the employer rate has now been reduced by 4.05% during that time. The rate reduction translates into the loss of about $160 million in revenue and, added to the two previous rate reductions, means that about $320 million in funding which could have been used to improve TRS benefits has been lost.

TRS Board of Trustee members are charged with the responsibility of 'serving the best interests of the retirement fund and the individual beneficiaries thereof.' TRS members are the beneficiaries not the employer(s).

While you have decreased the employer contribution rate three times, the employee rate was decreased only once and by only 1%. While members of the State Employees' Retirement System pay only a 1'% contribution rate, TRS members continue to be assessed 5%. TRS states that in order for the employee contribution rate to decrease the Georgia code will have to be amended. Why did TRS not suggest this code change or truly advocate for benefit improvements to state legislators? Instead of being advocates for the members you are charged to serve, you choose to be content with a growing fund that has not substantially improved benefits in nearly 20 years.

These facts are even more disappointing considering the structural portfolio that TRS increased by almost $2 billion during the last year ($1,909,038,918). Why can these gains not be transferred into improved benefits? At the very least, TRS could have passed on improvements in benefits to those who have retired. It seems hypocritical for TRS to even think of advancing through the legislative process House Bill 822, the bill that would provide a much needed COLA to retirees, when it neglected the opportunity and responsibility to provide essentially the same benefit improvements.

A brief history of TRS reveals that in 1970 the benefits included vesting after 20 years, retirement after 35 years of creditable service, disability benefits after 20 years, and a benefit ratio of 1.75%. During the next 12 years, GAE was successful in advocating legislation which decreased the vesting and disability benefit period to 10 years (1973); increased the benefit formula to 2% (1.76% 1975, 1.78% 1976, 1.80% 1977, 1.84% ' 1978, 1.88% 1979, 1.92% 1981, and 2% 1982); and full retirement benefits without penalty after 30 years of creditable service (1975, after 31 years in 1974). You should fully understand why TRS members are so disgruntled with the Board of Trustees for failing to become a partner in their quest to drastically improve benefits. Remember that the legislation to permit retirement after 25 years of service has a 7% per year penalty which ranks among the highest of any state and the ability to apply unused sick leave for retirement credit took two years to fund even though the cost was minimal.

Had we been as successful during the last 20 years with benefit improvements as we were during the 1970s, TRS members would not be as mistrustful of Trustee members who appear not to be serving the best interests of TRS members. Our beginning teachers are determined to achieve the ability to choose a portable retirement plan, like a 401K option, instead of joining TRS. Governor Barnes will most likely recommend the employer rate reduction for general budget items instead of improving employee benefits.

A comparison of Georgia's TRS benefits and employer rate with other southern states reveals that we are further behind. For example, Alabama provides full retirement after 25 years of service; Arkansas after 28 years, Kentucky after 27 years, Louisiana after 20 years, Mississippi after 25 years, and South Carolina after 28 years. The employer contribution rate is 12% in Arkansas, 13.05% in Kentucky, 14.2% in Louisiana, 9.75% in Mississippi, and 15% in West Virginia.

During the recent meetings of the House, Senate, and joint Retirement Committees, the message from TRS was the same, 'give us the money and we will administer the benefit improvement.' Why could you have not delayed the employer contribution reduction vote until the legislature met in 2002 and advanced the proposal with major benefit improvement suggestions? The majority of legislators are anxious to improve TRS benefits; however, because of your untimely, employee unfriendly action on May 23, they are told funds are not available. TRS members need true advocates on the Board of Trustees who are concerned with improving the benefit structure.

GAE will be advocating needed changes in the TRS structure in order to better meet the needs of TRS members during the next legislative session. Your action, which occurred without discussion or audience input, was disheartening and extremely unfriendly to our valuable members.