Skip to content
Georgia Association of Educators
Georgia Association of Educators schoolhouse mark Georgia Association of Educators Support · Protect · Strengthen
Toll free in Georgia1 800 282 7142
Join GAE

Whistleblower law a required ingredient for bolstering confidence in public schools

October 4, 2004

Atlanta ''To us this is a no brainer,' said Dr. Mechuria Chase Williams, president of the Georgia Association of Educators (GAE).'But for reasons unknown it seems to be threatening to others, mainly the administration.'Williams is referring to the opposition from school boards and superintendents to a whistleblower protection law proposed by GAE during the 2004 legislative session.

The bill, which was attached to Gov. Perdue's ethics package, died along with the package in the final hours of the 2004 legislature.When asked whether the bill would be resurrected, Williams did not hesitate. 'Yes, by all means,' she asserted.'We feel it is a vital component in the ongoing process of building our citizens' confidence in their public schools.More than ever, local school boards have more flexibility in funding and policy decisions.Such a law would not affect boards acting in good faith with state funds and policy.It only would penalize those guilty of taking action against honest employees who reported what they felt to be mismanagement and misappropriation of state, federal, and local funds and/or policies.I cannot fathom why anyone would not want such possibilities investigated.'

The law would entitle educators to disclose 'violations of law, rule, regulation, ordinance, or policy that pose a risk to public health, safety, or the environment without suffering adverse employment consequences or fear of reprisal.'The educator would be entitled to damages awarded through legal action if the school board or administrator retaliates.The burden to prove the retaliation would be on the employee.Williams says this necessary protection for school employees will help ensure the safe and proper operation of our schools and bolster public trust.

Whistleblower legislation is a good thing, especially when applied to issues of public funds and policies says Williams. 'Whistleblower legislation bolsters accountability,' she said. 'It keeps the issue in focus for everyone concerned.As a parent, I would want to know if my child was in a classroom that was over the legal limit for the teacher/student ratio.But the majority of parents are much too busy earning a living to follow up on whether schools are adhering to policies that directly impact their children.In one way schools and school systems are no different than any other business or government entity.They too are open to possible incidences of fraud, misconduct, mismanagement, etc.In another way, however, they are very different in that these incidences ultimately will affect our children.'

Williams points to TIME magazine's 2003 person of the year honors as an example of the need for such legislation.The 'person' turned out to be two courageous individuals who risked their careers by publicizing the misconduct of executive officials.Colleen Rowley of the FBI reported the mishandling of the 9 11 investigation, and Cynthia Cooper of WorldCom revealed a billion dollar debt that was not reported to investors.'However,' noted Williams, 'if the two had been employees of Georgia's public schools, they would have been subjected to dismissal, harassment, demotion, suspension, and reprisals because Georgia does not have a public employee whistleblower protection law.Without such protection, school employees have been, and will continue to be, reluctant to report alleged transgressions.'What type of transgressions'How about a second year kindergarten teacher in southeast Georgia who was assigned three students above the maximum class size and was told she would be fired if she reported the violation to DOE.

'Educators are under increased scrutiny and pressure and are expected to report incidences of misconduct and violations of law,' continued Williams.How much pressure? She reminds us that the Gwinnett County district attorney once said, 'To not report a felony is to commit a felony.'

She notes that many administrators instruct education employees to ignore certain problems because a report might endanger public trust of school officials.Gwinnett County school officials did not report over 90% of the student discipline problems handled by teachers and Education Support Professionals (ESP) in 2002 as required by the Department of Education.During the same period, Atlanta City Schools did not report a single student discipline problem in more than ' of their schools.

###