Skip to content
Georgia Association of Educators
Georgia Association of Educators schoolhouse mark Georgia Association of Educators Support · Protect · Strengthen
Toll free in Georgia1 800 282 7142
Join GAE

NCLB: Catchy name conceals need for major fixes in problematic law

September 21, 2004

Atlanta ' The confusion and frustration that accompanied meeting last year's initial milestones of President Bush's No Child Left Behind (NCLB) law ' the re authorization of the Elementary and Secondary Education Act (ESEA) continue to linger as Georgia enters the 2004 2005 school year, according to the state's most politically active educators' group.'As we have said from the beginning, while the title leaving no child behind plays well politically and emotionally and with the public,' said Dr. Merchuria Chase Williams, president of the 40,000 member Georgia Association of Educators (GAE), 'it is the fine print that has the most impact on our children.Of course no one wants to leave any child behind.This is the main goal for which our members on the front line strive for everyday.However, NCLB is a law that needs major adjustments if it is going to meet the noble goal of its promotional title.Frankly, in its current state, no child left behind leaves much to be desired.'


The GAE and the NEA [National Education Association] list ten changes that must take place for ESEA to become a viable and effective law:

1.Expand school accountability beyond the current measure of the percent of students proficient on one day on two tests (reading and math).

Allow states to incorporate additional measures into an accountability index to measure schools.Such measures could include attendance, graduation and dropout rates, percentage of students taking honors and AP classes, and results from other state and local assessments.Under ESEA, other academic indicators can only increase the number of schools that fail to make Adequate Yearly Progress (AYP).Schools get no credit for positive improvements on any other academic indicator.

2.Provide additional flexibility in using test scores to measure schools.

Under ESEA, states and schools are limited in using test scores.The only measure is a snapshot of the percent of students proficient or above on the day of the test.Unless they meet the yearly proficiency percentage, schools get no credit (with the limited exception under Safe Harbor) for growth in the percentage of students who are proficient over time, or for moving student achievement levels up on other points of the achievement scale (such as from below basic to basic or from proficient to advanced).Schools get no credit for longitudinal growth in student achievement, such as how students in a particular grade have improved from the beginning of the year to the end of the year, or how a group of students have improved as they advance in grade level.GAE/NEA propose to allow the state to utilize AYP academic growth models that acknowledge progress in student achievement both over time and within the school year.

3.Provide flexibility in the current requirement that 95 percent of students overall and in each subgroup must take the test.

A school will fail AYP if just one subgroup of students falls one percentage point short of the required 95 percent participation rate, even if all of its students exceed the required proficiency levels on the test.Nationwide, thousands of schools have been labeled as failing to meet federal standards because literally one or two children did not take the test.GAE/NEA propose that reasonable flexibility be provided, such as by lowering the 95 percent level to 90 percent participation, allowing averaging over three years of participation (as is now allowed in averaging test scores over three years), and setting an absolute minimum number of students (such as 5 10) in a subgroup that fail to take the test before counting as failing AYP.

P NOTE: On March 29, 2004, Sec. Paige adopted part of this proposal by allowing states to average test participation rates by up to three years.He also is allowing states and schools to exempt from the participation requirement students who were absent due to a medical emergency.However, he did not lower the threshold from 95% to 90%, nor set an absolute minimum number of children to be absent before a school fails to make AYP.

4.Provide flexibility and more reasonable rules for assessing English Language Learners (ELL).

Currently, if a student is a newly arrived immigrant to the United States, he or she must take the required reading and math tests even if such student has been in this country for only one day.GAE/NEA proposes to exempt students from the participation requirement until they have been in the United States for one full academic year.Additionally, since standardized reading and math tests are not available in the multitude of languages spoken by students, this results in students taking the test in English prior to their being proficient in English. GAE/NEA propose giving states the option to exempt from AYP purposes test scores for ELL students until they have been in the United States for three years.They would still be required to take the tests and have their scores reported by subgroup.Alternatively, students who become proficient in English should still count in the ELL subgroup for 3 years.Otherwise, it is simply impossible for this subgroup to ever reach the 100 percent proficiency level in reading in English, since part of the criteria for being in the ELL group is not being proficient in English.

PNOTE: On February 19, 2004, Sec. Paige announced new policies that implement parts of this proposal.States are now allowed to exempt from taking the reading test immigrant students who have been in the United States for less than one year.However, such students must still take the math test.In addition, states may now count 'exited' ELL students in the ELL subgroup for up to two years.

5.Limit designating schools as in need of improvement, corrective action, or restructuring to those schools where the same subgroup of students in the same subject fails to meet AYP for two or more consecutive years.

As an example, currently if in year one every subgroup met AYP in both reading and math, except for Hispanic students in reading, and the next year the school improves Hispanic student achievement in reading, but just one other subgroup fails to meet proficient levels in reading, the school is considered in need of improvement, even though the school addressed the needs of Hispanic students in reading.While the Department of Education has said that states may limit identifying schools for improvement to the case of one or more subgroups failing in the same subject, it refused several states' requests to limit it to the same subgroup in the same subject.

6.Target choice and supplemental services to students in the particular subgroups that are not meeting AYP standards.

Currently, if just one subgroup fails to meet AYP standards, then ALL children in the school, not just those in that subgroup, or those who are individually not proficient, have the right to paid transportation to another public school that has made AYP.In the case of supplemental educational services, while this option is limited to low income children, it again is not targeted to those needing the most academic help.As AYP is currently structured, 26,000 schools have already failed to meet AYP for at least one year, with 6,000 failing to make AYP for two or more years.Over time, ever increasing numbers of children will be seeking even fewer spots in other public schools, resulting in overcrowding, increased class size, and possible resegregation problems.Targeting these options to specific subgroups will help avoid these problems, while also ensuring that those students with the greatest needs get the assistance.

7.Recognize the unique teaching responsibilities of special education teachers.

Currently, many teachers of students with disabilities teach such children multiple subjects.Under ESEA such teachers must demonstrate content knowledge in each and every subject.Doing this places an unreasonable and possibly unobtainable burden on special education teachers and will likely make it even more difficult for schools to address the shortage of qualified special education teachers.GAE/NEA propose that a special education teacher who is fully licensed and certified in special education should be considered to meet the ESEA highly qualified rules.

8.Recognize the unique situation of small rural schools in meeting the highly qualified teacher requirement.

In particular middle schools face a difficult challenge, since due to their small size it will not be possible for them to have a separate fully certified and licensed biology, chemistry, physics, and earth science teacher.States should be given flexibility in how middle schools in general and small rural schools in particular meet the highly qualified requirements.

PNOTE: On March 15, 2004, Sec. Paige announced three new policies on 'highly qualified' teachers that adopt parts of this NEA proposal.Under the new policies, current teachers in rural school districts who teach multiple subjects will have one additional year (until the end of the 2006 07 school year) to become highly qualified in such additional subjects.Newly hired teachers in rural schools will have three years from their date of hire to become highly qualified in additional subjects they teach.In addition, states that have a 'broad based' science certification can consider teachers with such certification to be "highly qualified" in any science discipline.Finally, states may establish a streamlined process under the High Objective Uniform State Standard of Evaluation (HOUSSE) for teachers of multiple subjects to demonstrate they are competent in each of their subjects.While these policies allow teachers in rural schools more time to prove their 'competency' in multiple subjects and allow a streamlined process for other teachers, they still require such teachers to prove their competency in each of the multiple subjects they teach.The policies also fail to recognize broad based certification in social science.Finally, The Secretary has said that it is optional for states to have a HOUSSE.GAE/NEA believe the law requires that each state establish a HOUSSE.

9.Provide the resources and flexibility for Title I paraprofessionals to meet ESEA requirements.

Under ESEA all Title I paraprofessionals must either have an associate degree, two years of college courses, or meet a state or local assessment of their knowledge of and ability to assist with instruction in reading, writing, and math.Since the average salary of a paraprofessional is only $17,300, it will be a major financial burden on most paraprofessionals to pay for any needed college courses, test preparation, or the cost of tests.NEA proposes that school districts using federal funds pay any costs incurred by paraprofessionals or provide them the training needed to meet the new requirements.In addition, the law should make clear that each paraprofessional has the right to decide which of the three options to use to meet the standard.

10.Ensure that federal funds do not subsidize discrimination.

Secretary Paige has ruled that federal civil rights laws generally do not cover supplemental education service providers.In addition, he has said that any faith based entity receiving funds under ESEA programs may discriminate on the basis of religion in employment.GAE/NEA believe that any entity receiving funds under any ESEA program must fully comply with all federal civil rights laws.Finally, in another ruling, the Secretary has determined that supplemental service providers are not required to serve students with disabilities or Limited English Proficient students.GAE/NEA propose that, just as public schools must serve all students, so should supplemental service providers.

The U.S. Department of Education on August 2 [2004] released a first year report (http://www.ed.gov/rschstat/eval/disadv/supplementalyear1/index.html) on the Supplemental Educational Services (SES) provisions of ESEA/NCLB.The report examines implementation in nine school districts in six states'all of them farther along on implementation than most'and analyzes the efforts of states, districts, providers, and parents during the 2002 03 school year.

Although the report only highlighted the positive findings, there also were a number of alarming conclusions.These include: SES providers often failed to serve the needs of rural areas as well as students with disabilities or limited English proficiency, few providers confirmed that their curricula were aligned with state or district standards, provider efforts to communicate with teachers and parents were varied and erratic, and parents said they like and trust their children's schools and teachers even though the school is identified for improvement.

Williams concluded, 'We want every child in Georgia to have the opportunity to reach his or her fullest potential.In order to accomplish this we need to stop wasting resources on bureaucracy and high stakes testing.What our children need are smaller classes; more parental involvement; quality teaching; and up to date technology, books and materials.Once these components are truly in place and viably working, we will be on our way to leaving no child behind.'

###