April 15, 2004
By Merchuria Chase Williams
President, Georgia Association of Educators
Education policymakers from Washington, D.C. visited Augusta Thursday to hear testimony from a few of Georgia's education officials about how the so called 'No Child Left Behind' law is working in our state.Had they spoken with the people dealing with the day to day impact of this law on our children and schools, they would have heard a more troubling story.
The law's overly rigid demands and lack of adequate funding to make them work have created a nationwide backlash.A growing chorus of teachers, parents, principals and state and local policymakers of both parties have been raising serious, legitimate concerns about how it is interfering with their ongoing efforts to boost student achievement.
First, let's look at the funding.Like most other states, Georgia has been grappling with a serious budget crisis, and education spending has been cut by 14 percent over the last three years.
Georgia's students have already felt the impact of this state and local funding crunch.Schools have been forced to lay off teachers, raise class sizes, delay textbook purchases and maintenance, cut back on bus routes and basic classroom supplies, and raise taxes.No Child Left Behind is making all of this worse.
The law requires cash strapped schools and school districts to develop and administer student tests, track student performance, and raise test scores for groups of students falling behind.Those school districts that fall short have to use scarce dollars to pay for transferring students to other schools, tutoring, or even restructuring entire schools.
To meet the mandates of this law, cash strapped school systems' resources are being stretched to the breaking point. But the federal government has consistently failed to provide states with the necessary resources.In Georgia alone, the President's proposal for this upcoming fiscal year falls more than $200 million short of what was promised under the law for economically disadvantaged children.If enacted, this budget would leave more than 90,000 children from low income families behind.
The other big problem with No Child Left Behind is its one size fits all approach to evaluating school and student progress.We know that children learn at different rates and in different ways, but the law relies too much on one test as a snapshot to evaluate student progress.According to a recent poll by the National PTA, eight out of 10 parents oppose using testing as the only factor to measure student progress.
In its current form, No Child Left Behind and the extra bureaucracy and paperwork it has generated are keeping classroom teachers from providing each student with the individualized attention he or she needs.
Rather than just labeling and punishing schools, federal and state policymakers should be focused on providing more of the things that work:smaller class sizes, early childhood education, new textbooks and technology, and incentives to attract and retain quality teachers.
Georgia's educators are working hard to make the goals of No Child Left Behind a reality for all children.But so far federal policymakers and bureaucrats have not kept their promise to children and public education.It's time for them to listen to the voices of teachers and other educators on the front lines about how best to fix and fund this law.