Skip to content
Georgia Association of Educators
Georgia Association of Educators schoolhouse mark Georgia Association of Educators Support · Protect · Strengthen
Toll free in Georgia1 800 282 7142
Join GAE

Merit pay for teachers too flawed to be fair

The following was in response to an Atlanta Journal Constitution (1 13 2006) editorial.
January 12, 2006

AJC Equal Time

To the Editor:

It is inevitable, that whenever discussions of salary increases take place, the topic of salary schedule versus merit pay arises. While the goal of merit pay is admirable, there are inherent problems with its fair and equitable implementation.

A recent Urban Institute examination of merit pay in eighteen school districts illustrates the problems with implementing merit pay. While the authors report some positive short lived effects of merit pay reduced turnover and absenteeism, greater goal orientation, increased engagement in constructive and innovative activities they conclude that most plans had "major problems." Those included (1) teacher morale problems from increased competition and divisiveness; (2) teachers being upset because they did not get the awards they deserved; (3) the use of quotas on the number of teachers who could receive awards; and (4) the plans were costly and time consuming. Their review of other studies found "little evidence from other research, including the evaluation literature, that incentive programs (particularly pay for performance) had led to improved teacher performance and student achievements."
During the Barnes' administration, GAE began to advocate for a tiered certification professional teaching salary advancement instrument. The Georgia Professional Standards Commission has since explored this process. Tiered certification provides a method for teachers to advance in their profession without leaving the classroom.
GAE's recommended levels of tiered certification include:
  • Level one would be for Education Support Professionals (ESP) who are required to obtain certification of any kind (bus drivers, paraprofessionals, etc.);

  • Level two is a Teacher during the first two to five years of initial certification;
  • Level three is the Accomplished Teacher status which can be achieved after the first two years of experience and completion of state standards;

  • Level four is a Mentor Teacher who has increased responsibilities in the school system including serving as a mentor to new teachers;

  • Level five is a Master Teacher who has achieved the standards prescribed by the state that may include National Board Certification; and

  • Level six is an Administrator level that ensures anyone who becomes an administrator has achieved a high level of state standards.
Each of these levels is achieved with experience, professional development, and increased responsibility or participation in the school or school system. Each level also comes with a salary incentive and the ability to advance one's teaching career while remaining a classroom teacher.
Merit pay is best used when individual performance is valued and accurately measured across the board. It has proven problematic in a profession as complex as teaching where professionals don't have control over their students' innate ability and where they must discern the most effective way to reach and motivate each individual student to learn.
Very truly yours,

Merchuria Chase Williams, Ph.D.
President, Georgia Association of Educators