Skip to content
Georgia Association of Educators
Georgia Association of Educators schoolhouse mark Georgia Association of Educators Support · Protect · Strengthen
Toll free in Georgia1 800 282 7142
Join GAE

NCLB's unfunded mandates, high stakes test, and attendance issues creating quagmire for communities

Fall 2003

Noble goals dragged down by inadequacies

ATLANTA ' The leadership of the Georgia Association of Educators (GAE) feels that the authors and proponents of No Child Left Behind (NCLB) had noble intentions when it was hailed as the rescuer of our nation's public education system.'Leaving no child behind plays well politically and emotionally,' said GAE President Merchuria Chase Williams, 'but sometimes it's not your goal, but the path you take to get there that makes or breaks the final outcome.Of course no one wants to leave any child behind.Of course we want every child to have a quality teacher.Of course we want every child to realize his or her potential.These are worthy and noble goals for which to aspire and our members on the front line strive for this everyday.'

But so far the only results of NCLB's implementation seem to be confusion, labeling, and frustration.Were these supposed to be the by products of the latest sweeping federal education reform legislation'To hear its authors tell it no.But GAE's leadership says the signs were there from the beginning.'It's almost as if in a backhanded way, the ESEA [Elementary and Secondary Education Act] legislation was written to stack the deck against students, parents, teachers, and our public schools,' said GAE President Merchuria Chase Williams.'Frustration and confusion are the early by products, but I see anger quickly winning out, anger primarily because it affects our children.'

Williams says that communities across Georgia are feeling 'beaten up' after the first implementation deadlines for NCLB.'I don't need to reiterate the

problems that are being published and broadcast in our local areas,' she said, 'but people need to realize that NCLB was fraught with question marks before its passage.Chief among those questions marks were funding for resources needed to reach mandated goals, basing everything on one high stakes test, and

dubious attendance objectives.It also was patched together without significant input from educators who would have foreseen these problems.'

'First and foremost, NCLB is one huge unfunded mandate, the full repercussions of which will overwhelm many communities as they struggle to reach goals that for many are simply unobtainable mainly due to very little or no funding,' said Williams.'It is the classic 'Catch 22.'Under NCLB, school systems and communities will be required to provide all manner of remedies for not meeting stated goals, but there is no federal money following the edicts.Local communities, already stretched to the limit, realistically cannot come up with the funding for their remedies without throwing the proverbial 'baby out with the bath water.'And in this case the 'baby' refers to our children and public schools.'

'Next,' said Williams, 'NCLB's testing component to determine 'Adequate Yearly Progress' [AYP] is the best proof yet of why high stakes testing is not the be all to end all.All children, from special education through vocational to those on the college prep track, are required to pass the SAME TEST [The exception being those students with the most severe cognitive disabilities who take the Georgia Alternative Assessment test].Those on the college prep track have the best preparation for passing the test, yet the entire school will be 'labeled' should special ed or limited English proficiency students stumble.This legislation hurts teaching and learning by trying to fit all children into a one size fits all model.The reality is that different children learn differently and at different rates.Children need to be assessed by their individual body of work ' homework, participation, presentations, etc. ' not simply on one test score on one given day.Testing is linear, most children are not.'

Williams adds that GAE always has opposed high stakes testing which forces a decline in the teaching of critical thinking skills and by default creates an environment of overwhelming stress and strain for students who know all too well the dire implications of not passing.In addition, she notes that already many smaller communities have been caught in a no win situation.'If 98 percent of your schools have been identified as not meeting AYP due to any single trigger or combination of triggers in NCLB, to what school are parents going to transfer their children?'

Among many other deficiencies in NCLB, Williams notes that another challenge lies in the definition of'highly qualified teacher,' which NCLB defines as one who is certified in his or her field.She says the definition is unclear and does not take into consideration the certification requirements from past reforms.For example, she points out that before NCLB, middle grade teachers were required to earn a general certification.'This will be a dilemma for Georgia because middle grades and special education teachers are issued general certificates,' said Williams. 'Likewise in the elementary grades, teachers teach everything ' English, science, social studies, math, etc., and do not concentrate on one 'field.'And there is no forgiveness of this very common fact in NCLB.Does this mean that a 20 year veteran teacher who has earned consistent outstanding evaluations and has positively shaped thousands of young minds is now considered to be unqualified to continue'How many additional hurdles will be thrown at these teachers?'

Williams says the state's paraprofessionals also are very concerned about NCLB.'Paraprofessionals are being required to be certified, yet they are being paid less and less,' she said.'Many find it difficult to pay for the education needed to become certified, and for those who do go back to school, their new pay won't reflect their upgraded education.What our dedicated paraprofessionals need is a state salary schedule that truly reflects their newly attained abilities.'

In conclusion, Williams says that much needs to be done simply on communicating the intricacies with NCLB.'This is such a complex piece of legislation for everyone,' she said, 'so we [GAE] have held seminars for our members to help explain the legislation and to help them navigate and understand its requirements and consequences.'

###