Skip to content
Georgia Association of Educators
Georgia Association of Educators schoolhouse mark Georgia Association of Educators Support · Protect · Strengthen
Toll free in Georgia1 800 282 7142
Join GAE

Concern and anger escalate over new teacher certification standards

February 24, 2004

ATLANTA ' A groundswell of concern and anger is building among educators across the state regarding the recent change in teacher certification standards enacted by the Georgia Professional Standards Commission (PSC).'I am hearing concern from educators, and from those currently enrolled in Georgia's college education programs, that these new standards are a slap in the face to those who have made the effort and expended their monies to obtain education degrees,' said Dr. Merchuria Chase Williams, president of the 40,000 plus member Georgia Association of Educators (GAE).'These changes only will serve to de professionalize the teaching profession.'

Williams is referring to the PSC's changes that now include allowing anyone with a college degree to simply pass a series of paper and pencil tests to obtain certification and the removal of a grade point average requirement for applicants who have been out of school for ten plus years.She says GAE believes that one's GPA always should be considered because it is an indicator of how well one has mastered his or her content area. 'The PSC claims these new measures will eliminate barriers and tear down prohibitive standards, but this is far from reality,' said Williams.'Yes, we have a teacher shortage, but temporary solutions, quick fixes and band aid approaches actually will do more harm than good.And what message is this sending to parents and students when at a time we are working diligently to place 'highly qualified' teachers in our classrooms and we send them under prepared teachers'What does this say about our effort to retain and support the dedicated, caring teachers now working on the front line?'

Williams explains that by 'under prepared' she is referring to the fact that just because someone may know his or her content area well, it does not equate to that person being able to impart that knowledge effectively.She says what is missing from this 'quick fix' standard is the pedagogy or 'how do you teach?'How do you get the content information across to a classroom of children with different learning styles, different attention spans, etc., while creating and maintaining an atmosphere of order in the classroom? She notes that this is especially true for special education classes that are challenging even for those teachers who have received the proper preparation.

Dr. Lucindia Chance, dean of the College of Education at Georgia Southern University and president of the Georgia Association of Colleges for Teaching Education said, 'I'm bothered that anything that was previously considered a standard is now viewed as an obstacle. When did standards become obstacles'All the PSC has accomplished is to find a way to get more teachers, faster. But that's a problem. These are the teachers who will go into the high need schools. And those are challenging enough if you have the best preparation in the world.'

Chance also calls into question the actual PSC vote for the changed standards.'Three new members were added to the PSC on the day that they voted three members who had not heard testimony. You can't help but think that they were brought on to vote the party line,' she added.

'Some people have this idealized vision that in classrooms across Georgia all children sit quietly and listen; are well behaved and don't bother their classmates; have had a good night's sleep; are not hungry; don't have emotional, physical or psychological problems; or have a caring parent or caregiver at home,' Williams said.'This is not reality. This is why, historically, teachers have had to go through the rigor of a college of education program.The programs prepare them for these realities.They show them that theory and practice are quite different and they give them the proven tools for success.'

Cassandra Arcioa is president of the GAE Student chapter at Georgia State University.Currently doing her student teaching at Cliff Valley Preschool, she says concerns among students are beginning to fester.'I've already talked to people who are just beginning our education program who are thinking about leaving, getting their four year degree in something else and then teaching if they want without any experience or education.The PSC's ruling makes us feel like the degrees we've been working so hard at don't mean a thing anymore. This is the profession we've chosen because we want to make a difference and we want to be good at it.'

Most teacher preparation programs will provide an internship in a real classroom setting for at least one full semester.Many address the differences in teaching in urban, suburban, and rural schools.They will teach how to work with a weak student in a strong group, how to do a seating chart, and why it's important sometimes to keep friends apart.''Quick fix' standards will not provide this knowledge base,' noted Williams.'What we need to be striving for is strengthening our process for certifying teachers for the long haul.In these times of rigid accountability, high standards, and expectations, it is imperative that we ensure persons entering the profession have the proper credentials, along multiple measures, to maximize their potential and give them a real chance at being successful.'

###