Fall 2003
ATLANTA ' It happens more often than one might think.A teacher is instructed by an administrator to circumvent or ignore a policy or rule.The teacher, caught between a rock and a hard place, acquiesces to the dictate out of fear of reprisal or loss of job.The ultimate loser in this scenario ' our children.So says the leadership of the 40,000 plus member Georgia Association of Educators who supports the passage of SB 254, the Whistle Blower Protection Act for Public School Employees.'As a parent, I would want to know if my child was in a classroom that was over the legal limit for the teacher/student ratio,' said GAE President Merchuria Chase Williams.'But the majority of parents are much too busy earning a living for their families to follow up on whether schools are adhering to policies that directly impact their children.In one way schools and school systems are no different than any other business or government entity.They too are open to possible incidences of fraud, misconduct, mismanagement, etc.In another way, however, they are very different in that these incidences ultimately will affect our children.'
Williams points to recent reports of non or under reporting of student discipline problems in two metro Atlanta school systems and an incidence in southeast Georgia where a teacher was told she would be fired if she reported to the Department of Education that her class size was three students over the limit.'I guarantee you that these incidences are just the tip of the iceberg,' she said.'They, however, would be less likely to happen if a law was passed that protected school employees who witness or knew of such violations.'
Williams says she really doesn't understand the argument by critics that passage of the legislation would amount to 'instant tenure.''The legislation states that this protection would only apply to person(s) bringing forth violations in policies, procedures, and the like.It could not be used for incidences of reprisal for say a reprimand by a supervisor.It simply wouldn't work that way.Besides, I would think administrators would welcome any legislation that would help root out violations in their departments.'
SB 254 was unanimously approved by the Senate Special Judiciary Committee, Senate Rules Committee, the State Senate and the House Education Committee.However, the House Rules Committee did not approve the legislation for action by the full House.'We will be supporting passage of SB 254 as one of our highest priorities during the 2004 legislative session,' declared Williams.
Williams notes that TIME magazine awarded its annual person of the year honor to two courageous individuals who risked their careers by publicizing the misconduct of executive officials.Colleen Rowley of the FBI reported the mishandling of the 9 11 investigation, and Cynthia Cooper of WorldCom revealed a billion dollar debt that was not reported to investors.She added, 'If the two had been employees of Georgia's public schools, they would have been subjected to dismissal, harassment, demotion, suspension, and reprisals. Without such safeguards, school employees are reluctant to report allegations of mismanagement and misappropriation of state, federal, and local funds.Those on the front line must be encouraged to report violations of law, policy, and regulation without fear of harassment and retaliation in order to bring accountability to school systems.'
'We are at a time,' observed Williams, 'when local school boards are being provided more flexibility in funding and policy decisions.Legislators are allocating funds to local boards of education to lower class sizes; to employ education specialists [counselors, psychologists, social workers, speech pathologists and audiologists, and media personnel]; to add intervention programs to assist students not achieving at grade level; and for many other programs.Local school boards acting in good faith with state funds and policy would not be affected with passage of SB 254.It would only penalize those boards guilty of taking action against employees who, in good faith and honesty, reported such violations.'
###