Skip to content
Georgia Association of Educators
Georgia Association of Educators schoolhouse mark Georgia Association of Educators Support · Protect · Strengthen
Toll free in Georgia1 800 282 7142
Join GAE

Rebuttal to AJC editorial on fair dismissal (2003)

April 14, 2003

Editorial Rebuttal
Atlanta Journal Constitution

The membership of the Georgia Association of Educators (GAE) applauds the passage of an amended version of SB193.The amendment, offered by Senator Horacena Tate (Atlanta), and approved by the State Senate, will restore Georgia's fair dismissal rights equally for all teachers.
The media continue, however, to do a disservice to the public by erroneously referring to Georgia's Fair Dismissal Law as 'teacher tenure.'Tenure is earned by higher education professors, not by Georgia's k 12 classroom teachers.Fair dismissal for k 12 teachers provides a process for teachers to appeal a decision to not renew their teaching contracts because of malicious and/or political reasons.A perfect case in point was the situation with the 'Gwinnett Gateway' teacher James Hope.The courts and the Constitution agreed that Gwinnett County Schools needed to give up its witch hunt against Hope.Fair dismissal simply would give Hope, and many others like him around the state, the means by which to battle rash allegations that would ultimately hurt our children because these great teachers would no longer be encouraged to speak out on issues important to students.
Under SB193 teachers must serve a three year probationary period before earning fair dismissal. During this period a teacher is observed during classroom teaching, evaluated and provided an opportunity to improve ' should it be needed.Within that three timeframe, if a school system cannot determine a teacher's competency, then we would argue they have a serious management problem.Once legislators understood this issue, they overwhelmingly supported the GAE initiated bill with a 161 8 vote in the House of Representatives and a 53 0 vote in the Senate.SB193 requires local boards of education to provide veteran, qualified, competent teachers with a reason for their dismissal recommendation and a fair and impartial hearing.We believe that every citizen should be entitled to a due process procedure regarding employment.
Every state except Georgia and Mississippi provide fair dismissal rights to K 12 teachers.There is no evidence to link fair dismissal opportunities to poor student performance.Teachers who have not met acceptable standards can be dismissed.Fair dismissal simply guards against the dismissal being based on discriminatory treatment, arbitrary and capricious actions, unfounded allegations of misconduct, and other threats unrelated to competency.It encourages teachers to be innovative and creative for the benefit of their students without fear of reprisal.
We strongly support the passage of SB193 by the House and its signing by Governor Perdue.
Very truly yours,

Merchuria Chase Williams
President