Skip to content
Georgia Association of Educators
Georgia Association of Educators schoolhouse mark Georgia Association of Educators Support · Protect · Strengthen
Toll free in Georgia1 800 282 7142
Join GAE

Fair Dismissal (2002)

December 28, 2002
Dear Editor:
The Georgia Association of Educators (GAE) was the only organization to stand up against Gov. Barnes for the preservation of the Fair Dismissal Act for all teachers. GAE loudly protested the anti teacher rhetoric while PAGE supported Governor Barnes. It is apparent that by inviting Tim Callahan of PAGE to write an article on Georgia's Fair Dismissal policy for teachers, the AJC does not appear interested in conducting a serious debate on the issue. PAGE, Callahan, and rejected state school superintendent candidate Barbara Christmas, folded early in the debate by agreeing with Gov. Barnes for the removal of fair dismissal due process rights for teachers. PAGE ignored the opposition of teachers to the Act and encouraged legislators to vote for the bill. While GAE continues to pursue the reinstatement of fair dismissal rights, suddenly with the defeat of Barnes, PAGE is once again jumping on the GAE bandwagon and scrambling to put a new spin on its ill fated legislative surrender of teachers' rights.
Fair dismissal due process rights do not provide bad teachers with lifetime job security. Due process rights, afforded to teachers in every state except Georgia and Mississippi, protect good teachers from bad management. There is no better example of the need for providing every educator with a fair dismissal procedure than the case of James Hope in Gwinnett County. Hope had the courage to voice opposition to the over emphasis of student testing. He would have been fired for exercising his freedom of speech without fair dismissal protection. Hope's dismissal would have occurred even though he is recognized as a master teacher, was awarded Teacher of The Year, and was supported by his colleagues and community.
James Hope's case is not an isolated example. GAE provides legal representation to hundreds of teachers each year in everything from contract salary cases to certification disciplinary actions to dismissals. Many of the teachers the AJC editorial cited as annual resignations resign in the face of administrative threats. A fair dismissal process is the only protection separating the just from the unjust dismissals.
The heart of the teaching profession is academic freedom. Without due process protection teachers cannot be innovative and creative in classroom instruction without fear of reprisal. Fair dismissal protects teachers courageous enough to speak out for children and public education. By allowing administrators the right to fire any teacher at will without justification, academic freedom may be stifled and teachers harassed without holding those administrators accountable.
Sincerely,

Bob Cribbs, GAE Government Relations Director
Michael Kramer and Terence Thomas, GAE Associate Executive Directors