Multiple Factors Enter into the Cause and Solution of State's Dropout Challenge
Yes, Georgia's dropout rate is too high. No, the approximated 50% rate presented in recently released data is most likely not accurate due to Georgia's imprecise methods of gathering student mobility and graduation information over a five year period instead of the traditional four years.
But clearly, the rate is too high. Georgia is losing too many students, classified as low income, to the negative effects of poverty.
How can we fix the problem? Certainly, reducing class size will make a tremendous difference for our students' future, as will much better early intervention programs. However, we must address some significant social issues that impede student progress. We must also rethink the unforeseen consequences of education reform that, while may be unintended, actually may make matters worse.
First, we must drastically reduce the astoundingly high teen pregnancy rate in Georgia. Too many of our young girls are allowing predatory sexual practices to rob their future. The vast majority of pregnant teens drop out of school. If we can reduce the teen pregnancy rate, we will reduce the dropout rate.
We must significantly improve the scholastic instruction provided to Georgia's booming immigrant population. Georgia is not providing the resources our school systems need to bolster English Speaker's of Other Languages (ESOL) and immersion classes. If we improve the services to these tremendously talented students to make them successful in English and other languages, Georgia not only will reduce its dropout rate but also have a built in advantage in our future dealings in the international business world.
Georgia's teachers must receive the assistance of the business community and parents in order to solve the dropout problem. We are constantly told that the business community is the engine driving education reform. Why do Georgia's business leaders not establish a compact requiring a high school diploma for employment? Why are the critics who blame teachers for the dropout rate not insistent on holding parents accountable for making sure children attend school, obey discipline and instructional rules, and for creating an expectation for graduation?
Finally, there are both positive and negative consequences to all education reform movements. When policy makers cut out recess to get more academic time, their decision compounds discipline problems that reduce academic time. By placing the primary focus on the college bound students, we ignore vocational/technical students who are the overwhelming majority, and arguably the true backbone of our economy. When we set high standards that all should achieve and mandate only one test as the way to measure that standard, we ignore the latest educational research on learning that suggests humans have many ways to demonstrate mastery of a concept. By eliminating art, music, and PE programs to provide more resources to math and science, we lose the creative spark that makes children love school and ignore the strong link between the arts and academic achievement. When we decide to emphasize only reading and math in elementary school, we should not be surprised when a high percentage of high school students cannot magically pass the science exit exam. As we dramatically raise the standards and expectations for teachers, but do not address the need for equally dramatic pay increases or improved supplies and teaching conditions we should not be surprised by the drastic teacher shortage that has led to plans to open the profession to any C average student.
Yes, we must reduce Georgia's dropout rate; we must do this as a society to help our children. As a political culture, we also must finally learn to listen to our teachers on educational issues. Georgia's future depends on it.
Ralph Noble
GAE President
May 22, 2001