Please forward this message to all educators concerned about the state health insurance crisis!
Today, the Board of Commissioners for the Department of Community Health held their monthly meeting and GAE was there to express the concerns of educators across this state. We also tried to get answers to questions that many of you are asking. The Board heard from several speakers (PAGE did not speak) who expressed frustration, anger and concern about UnitedHealthcare becoming the insurance provider for the State Health Benefit Plan (SHBP) for the PPO, Indemnity and High Deductible Health Plan (HDHP).
UnitedHealthcare (UHC) gave a presentation about their efforts to ensure physicians and facilities continue to join the network. They also addressed specifically the shortage of doctors in the southern and northern parts of the state. It was obvious from the presentation the heat that UHC has felt from physicians and patients as well about the problems of coverage across pockets of the state.
As GAE has reported in previous updates the problem for physicians and facilities in becoming a part of the network is with the contract they are being asked to sign. In the contract there is a clause that says physicians will accept 'all products' UHC offers. That means a doctor who signs a contract for the PPO program will have to accept the fee reimbursement structure, the programs and stipulations that go with the HMO provided by UHC, because it is one of their products. At least that is how it was explained to the DCH Board when they asked UHC representatives about that clause.
UHC was repeatedly asked by the DCH Board whether they would remove the 'all products' clause from the contract in order to get more doctors to sign up and they would not answer the question directly. One of the other issues physicians and facilities have had with the contract is it states that UHC could change its fee reimbursement structure at any time without notice to or permission from doctors. UHC did say they were NOW including a letter to physicians who have not yet joined the network that they would be given an opportunity to accept or decline any new fee structure that UHC may want to implement. This was news to the representatives for physicians who were present at the meeting.
After the Board asked questions of the UHC representatives they opened up the floor for public comment. Among those expressing the concerns of those affected by the changes in SHBP was Peggy Nielson, who represents southwest Georgia on the State Board of Education. She gave a wonderful speech about the impact this has had on educators. Peggy quoted many of you who attended the meeting she hosted last week in Albany on November 3rd. If you get an opportunity to email Peggy and thank her for her work on this issue, please do so, [email protected].
Jocelyn Whitfield, Director of Government Relations for GAE, testified before the Board of Community Health to convey the anger, frustration, disillusionment, and outrage that GAE members have been feeling about this issue. Due to time constraints she was not able to say all the things she wanted to, but her comments are below:
'I am Jocelyn Whitfield, representing the 40,000 member of GAE as well as their spouses, and dependents who are all a part of the State Health Benefit Plan. They could not be here today because they are busy educating the future of this state. I wish DCH would hold these meetings around the state during a time when you could hear directly from those educators who have been struggling through this process of switching to UnitedHealthcare. I have more questions and concerns to convey for our members than I could possibly express in the time we have here today, but I do want to touch on a few of the questions and frustrations they have been screaming to have heard.
I have been hearing things from teachers and education employees, such as 'school flu', 'sick outs', and even 'strike'. These are not words that are normally tossed around by educators. They want to be in the classroom teaching our kids, but they are frustrated, angry, hurt, scared and disappointed in their employer, the state of Georgia . While teachers do not enter this profession to become rich, they do expect to be provided with quality benefits and over the last four or five years, they have seen those benefits eroded. This was just the final straw.
Because of the chorus of voices from educators across this state, and because it seemed as if DCH was not going to address the problem of the open enrollment deadline being upon us without a network of physicians in place, GAE contacted the Attorney General's office to ask for an injunction to require DCH to extend the open enrollment period. That next day the Governor and DCH announced the extension of the open enrollment period to November 18. We appreciate that change, but it does not go far enough to answer the concerns of educators across this state.
In education, politicians, superintendents, parents and bureaucrats are fond of tossing around the word 'accountability.' Accountability in bringing up test scores, accountability in ensuring no child is left behind, accountability for results in areas that are beyond the control of educators.
But for DCH, this was an area that was within your control and WHO IS GOING TO BE HELD ACCOUNTABLE?
Who is going to be accountable for DCH choosing an insurance provider that is facing a lawsuit from this state for non payment to providers?
Who is accountable for choosing UHC when they did not have a network of providers in this state?
Who is going to ensure this never happens again?
Who is going to answer the questions that physicians, educators and state employees continue to ask?
I want to thank Peggy Nielson for her comments and the work she has done on this issue. In addition to the meeting she held in Albany there was another meeting two days ago there with UHC representatives. Our members from that area reported that it was mostly a presentation about how wonderful UHC is and did not really address their questions because they were allotted only an hour. They also were concerned because part of the presentation was about the UHC HMO, which is not even available to those educators in the Albany area. This is the type of thing that adds to the frustration and anger of educators and state employees across this state. When they cannot get answers to their questions, there is a problem.
How will you reassure the teacher inAlbany who has been diagnosed with breast cancer and will have to drive more than 100 miles to receive chemo for the next 6 weeks that she won't have to drive those miles? How will she know that her oncologist will be in the network? How will she be able to teach her students if she is on the road all the time? How can she get healthy worrying about all of this? Who will answer her questions?
How will you reassure the teacher in
While GAE members and other state employees have struggled through this process GAE has been working to keep this from happening again. During the summer I met with many legislators to discuss sponsoring legislation that would require the appointment of two state employee representatives to the Board of DCH. We have the sponsors li ned up and I feel positive we will get the legislation passed.
Now, I don't say that to imply that you as a Board don't consider the consequences to state employees when you make these important decisions, but to say that their voice MUST be heard. You and the staff of DCH need to be out in the state holding meetings when educators can actually attend and hear their concerns, their anger and give answers to their questions.
There are more than 630,000 people covered under the State Health Benefit Plan and it is high time they were more than just numbers and that DCH looked at more than just the bottom line. Their voice must be heard.'
Some specific questions or comments that Jocelyn was not able to raise during her allotted time but got answers to some of them from staff after the meeting:
If the ultimate goal is to push everyone to Managed Care, then why not be upfront about that rather than contracting with a company who does not have a network large enough to support the PPO program, and ultimately forcing employees into managed care anyway.
The UHC slogan is 'It just makes sense.' Well, none of this makes sense to those employees who are struggling to pay their premiums, teach students, buy groceries and prescriptions, and make the correct choice for healthcare when they feel they don't have choices.
What about the Beech Street Network for those who live out of state? Answer from DCH staff: That will no longer exist but the UHC network is nationwide and most of the doctors in the Beech Street network will be in UHC's network.
What about those who want to eliminate the tobacco surcharge but have to take a smoking cessation class, even though they are not offered across the state? Answer from DCH staff: We are working with the American Cancer Society to expand the number of classes around the state and will hopefully have many more by the time the new enrollment year begins. If a person has been tobacco free for the last 12 months they can eliminate the surcharge without taking the cessation class.
What about those employees who have dependents li ving out of state or out of the HMO network area? Answer from DCH staff: There is an out of network agreement that may be offered by the HMO for certain areas outside the state. The employee should check with the HMO provider to find out what options are available. For emergency care the HMO will usually honor the out of network costs, but for regular doctor's visits it may require the dependent to travel back the HMO network for care.
After Jocelyn's comments Board member Dr. Chris Stroud (a physician from Albany , who has not joined UHC's network) stated that the DCH Board had no part in the decision to contract with UnitedHealthcare.
That is exactly why GAE asked the question about accountability because it has become painfully obvious that the decisions about UHC being chosen (despite all the evidence showing they should not have been) were made without input from those who would be most impacted by it. These decisions must be thoughtful, with the best interest of the state and its employees in mind. There must be accountability.
Not only has GAE been working to ensure representation of educators on the DCH Board, but we have been meeting with legislators all over the state to discuss legislative changes to hold DCH accountable and to make sure the decisions they make are sound ones.
There is no real oversight of DCH by the General Assembly or the Governor's office, at least one would have to assume that or how else could these horrible decisions have been made?
GAE will continue to work to change this and we need everyone to join us in this effort. If you have not already emailed the Governor (http://www.gov.state.ga.us/contact_dom.shtml) you should do so now.
If you have not contacted SHBP to let them know your frustrations, do so. http://services.georgia.gov/esp/survey.do'surveyId=2223
If you know of someone who is a PAGE member and they believe their concerns are being voiced by PAGE, please let them know they did not have a voice today at this important meeting.