Skip to content
Georgia Association of Educators
Georgia Association of Educators schoolhouse mark Georgia Association of Educators Support · Protect · Strengthen
Toll free in Georgia1 800 282 7142
Join GAE

Historic Legal Victories

James Hope'The Gateway Whistleblower
A long time opponent of the Gwinnett County's controversial Gateway exam, James Hope wanted to raise awareness about how poorly the high stakes test is designed, and believed that he had a responsibility to do so. Hope posted six of the poorly worded and confusing test questions on the Concerned Parents of Gwinnett's Web site. Hope had already administered the exam to his class and he knew that the six questions were never to be used again.
Gwinnett County Public Schools, however, alleged that Hope's actions violated the portion of the Code of Ethics dealing with standardized tests. As a result, the school system launched an aggressive investigation and prosecution of Hope that lasted three years. According to Hope's GAE attorney Terry Thomas, Gwinnett County school officials chose to ignore that, under the Open Records Act, the Gateway test questions are available to all citizens, without exception.
School officials sent armed police to Hope's home; he was ordered to undergo a lie detector test administered by a Georgia Bureau of Investigation agent; police confiscated his phone records, and interrogated his colleagues and friends; and, in a particularly heinous move, authorities threatened Hope and his wife with jail time and with having their daughter taken away from them. Following its investigation, Georgia's Professional Standards Commission (PSC) recommended that Hope's teaching certificate be suspended. In a hearing held in early 2002, Administrative Law Judge Catherine Crawford delivered a decision that Hope had violated the Code of Ethics and that his certificate should be suspended for six months. GAE attorneys immediately appealed the decision and later represented Hope during the appeal.
In December of 2002, GAE's Terry Thomas successfully persuaded Fulton County Superior Court Judge Gail S. Tuscan to clear Hope of misconduct charges.
GAE Wins Class Action Backpay Case for 4,000 Regents Faculty
The Georgia Court of Appeals held up a 2002 ruling by Fulton County Superior Court Judge Elizabeth Long resulting in 4,000 statewide faculty of the Board of Regents' University System of Georgia's member colleges collecting several days of backpay for merit salary increases denied them at the start of the 1998 1999 school year. The total amount of backpay plus interest was over $700,000 and breaks down to between $100 $200 per faculty member.
Polk County Pays Over $500,000 in Local Salary Supplements
GAE's General Counsel and the Law Firm Kramer & Thomas, LLC brought a class action lawsuit in January 2004 for over 350 Polk County teachers. As a result of GAE's lawsuit and the terms of an agreed to settlement between GAE, the lead plaintiffs, and the school district, the school district issued checks to 350 teachers. More than 350 teachers received checks totaling over $500,000. The school district also paid attorneys fees and costs back to GAE for bringing the lawsuit.
Principal Cleared of Sexual Misconduct Charges
An elementary school principal was reinstated with the Atlanta Public School System effective May 1, 2002, after a parent falsely accused the 38 year educator'with an impeccable record'of improper sexual conduct. GAE Legal Services defended the principal and obtained a court ordered stay. GAE obtained clear evidence of the falsity of the parent's accusation. Negotiations then resulted in the principal's reinstatement. APS completely dismissed the charge of sexual misconduct.
Middle School Teacher Cleared
A Middle school teacher was in disbelief when he opened a letter from the Professional Standards Commission (PSC) informing him of a parent's complaint that he had used profanities in addressing her child. The PSC unjustly found probable cause of an ethics code violation and recommended that the teacher be reprimanded and monitored. GAE appealed the PSC's findings. In a hearing before an Administrative Law Judge, the GAE attorney successfully demonstrated that the parent had tried to persuade a witness to lie about the teacher's behavior. The Administrative Law Judge hearing the evidence and arguments dismissed the case.