Skip to content
Georgia Association of Educators
Georgia Association of Educators schoolhouse mark Georgia Association of Educators Support · Protect · Strengthen
Toll free in Georgia1 800 282 7142
Join GAE

Demoted Atlanta Public Schools' (APS) principal wins reinstatement and back pay

January 9, 2003
Court overturns APS decision upheld by State Board of Education

ATLANTA ' Robert Robbins, a former principal of Campbell Elementary School in Atlanta, who was summarily demoted by the APS and whose demotion was upheld by the State Board of Education, won his case in Fulton County Superior Court for full reinstatement to his position and for compensation of all back pay and benefits for the time he was demoted.

During the 1999 2000 school year, Robbins, then principal at Campbell Elementary, had 13 special education students transferred to him by the APS. However, APS did not fulfill its promise to provide a special education teacher for those students. Robbins realized that APS, by not providing that teacher, was in violation of federal regulations regarding student teacher ratios for special education students. To ensure that the students received service and to protect APS from federal penalties, Robbins took it upon himself to obtain a special education teacher for the students. He discovered that a para professional in his school was one credit away from special education certification. Due to the severe teacher shortage, especially for special education teachers, he assigned this staff member to the class. After he informed APS that he had come up with a solution for the problem, they demoted him to teacher although Robbins had already signed a contract for the coming year to stay on as principal.

In his decision, Fulton County Superior Court Judge Rowland W. Barnes stated that Robbins 'was faced with the classic 'Hobson's choice'' and that Robbins' actions did not constitute a willful neglect of duties as the APS had stated. Barnes also gave Robbins the benefit of the doubt regarding his decision to pay for and allow the para professional to attend a class to obtain his certification.

Robbins, who was elated at the decision, said he was just trying to do the right thing for the children that were placed in his charge. 'The bottom line was that I had 13 students that needed the best teacher I could provide for them, regardless of the circumstances,' he said. 'I am just relieved that this entire ordeal is over and that justice has been served.'

Terry Thomas, associate executive director for the Georgia Association of Educators (GAE) and Robbins' legal counsel, noted that the APS placed Robbins between a rock and a hard place. 'With his proverbial 'back against the wall' Mr. Robbins chose in favor of his students and paid dearly for that choice,' Thomas said. 'But actions such as this are simply the tip of the iceberg. There are hundreds of Robbins out there in our schools who put their livelihoods on the line everyday for the sake of their students. They will choose in favor of their students every time. Fortunately, Mr. Robbins chose to fight back.'

'Circumstances such as those brought forth in this case further illustrate the need for the reinstatement of fair dismissal statewide for educators,' added Thomas. 'This is something GAE has been and with the new administration will continue to be working toward.'

###

To view the decision documents visit:
http://www.fcclk.org/JudicialSearch/ISAPI/TSGProxy.dll/fulton/get/images/cvcm0387/390305.tif