FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE May 5, 2010
ATLANTA The Georgia Association of Educators (GAE) today held a press conference to express its opposition to Georgia's re application for federal Race To The Top funding. The following are excerpts from a letter being sent from GAE to U.S. Secretary of Education Arne Duncan on the reasons why:
'I am writing on behalf of the 43,000 members of the Georgia Association of Educators (GAE), the state affiliate of the National Education Association to formally express our opposition to Georgia's Phase 2 Race to the Top application.
GAE has the following areas of concern with the application:
State Success Factors
Section (A)(1)(ii) ' (45 points) Neither the Governor nor representatives of his education staff ever requested the leadership of the two major professional education association's state or local affiliates in Georgia to participate in any of the Phase 1 or 2 task force work in order to solicit support to engage and empower Georgia's 200,000 public education employees to craft and implement the proposed reforms to bring lasting systemic change to our schools. GAE made repeated requests beginning in Fall 2009 from the state and local level to participate in the Race to the Top application process. The GAE firmly believes that true reform for public education cannot occur without collaboration at the state and local levels. Instead of inclusion in the process to reform our public schools, the Governor instead chose to exclude the voices of Georgia's educators belonging to professional education associations.
Section (A)(1)(iii) ' (15 points) Georgia's Phase 1 application had signed Memorandums of Understanding in 23 (12.7% percent) school systems, thereby not indicating broad statewide impact or support. The majority of Georgia's 1.6 million public school students would see no benefit of the Race to the Top program.
Section (A)(2)(ii)(a) ' (10 points) The state of Georgia did not engage 'The State's teachers and principals, which include the State's teacher unions or statewide teacher associations'(from national RT3 guidelines) to enlist support to implement the Phase 1 or 2 proposals. Rather than engage over 120,000 members of the two major associations, the Governor publicly stated that 'he rarely looks to professional associations for help'' (Atlanta Journal and Constitution, Schools vie for state money, Dec. 20, 2009.)
"Frankly, I [Perdue] find that our associations and not just those in education in general are typically there to represent the status quo, and it's my belief, and I think it's [U.S. Education] Secretary [Arne] Duncan's belief, that the status quo in education in America and in Georgia won't cut it for the future." (Atlanta Journal and Constitution, Schools vie for state money, Dec. 20, 2009.)
Despite repeated requests to meet with the Governor, GAE was limited to two twenty minute meetings with his education policy advisor. The GAE has repeatedly worked to participate in activities to reform public education throughout the state of Georgia.
'[Georgia's Superintendent of Schools, Kathy] Cox said she traditionally includes Georgia Association of Educators and the Professional Association of Georgia Educators in discussions of any major education initiative. "If I had been in charge, I think the [Race to the Top] committees would have looked different," she said.''(Atlanta Journal and Constitution, Schools vie for state money, Dec. 20, 2009.)
Again, the Georgia Association of Educators is committed to the improvement of our public schools. We do not feel that our 'non union' status should have excluded our organization from being active partners in the creation of the Race to the Top application at the state or local level. The expertise of our members and available resources from GAE could have greatly enhanced Georgia's application.
Great Teachers and Leaders
Section (D)(2)(ii) ' (15 points) GAE has worked with Superintendent Cox on the 'Class Keys' pilot program for teacher effectiveness and continues to support a common, statewide evaluation program for teachers and administrators. The proposed 'Class Keys' program still has major flaws to be worked out but does have the potential to be a solid instrument to gauge educator effectiveness. Unfortunately, in an effort to meet Governor Perdue's mandate to show progress toward the goals of 'Race to the Top,' his staff inserted evaluation language into legislation just before the end of this year's legislative session. The evaluation language did not pass.
Section (D)(2)(iv)(b) ' (28 points) GAE has proposed a six step tiered certification and compensation model each year since 2001 for consideration by the state legislature and Governor. During this year's legislative session, GAE opposed legislation to create a teacher compensation model (Senate Bill 386) due to major concerns regarding how compensation would be made available and awarded to the recipients at the expense of educators with advanced degrees and through the loss of cost of living adjustments. It is GAE's belief that, all things being equal, any compensation plan that increases one employee's compensation by reducing another's is unacceptable.
Low Achieving Schools
Section (E)(2)(ii) ' (35 points) GAE has significant concerns about the ability to implement intervention models for low achieving schools, particularly in rural areas due to geographic and personnel concerns should the turnaround or school closure model be chosen.
It is GAE's desire to be an active partner in providing a great public school education to every student in our state, and we truly want to be part of the process through which Race to the Top helps transform Georgia's public schools. However, given our severe concerns regarding the problems within several major goal areas and complete failure of the Governor and his staff to engage our professional education association to be part of the creation and buy in process regarding the Race to the Top competition, we must regretfully oppose the Phase 2 application for the state of Georgia.'
###