Skip to content
Georgia Association of Educators
Georgia Association of Educators schoolhouse mark Georgia Association of Educators Support · Protect · Strengthen
Toll free in Georgia1 800 282 7142
Join GAE

GAE Comments for Senate Ed and Youth Committee

February 11, 2010
Chairman Weber and members of the Committee.
Thank you for the opportunity to share our thoughts on Senate Bill 386. I would like to begin by stating that while several parties have been gracious to my organization by providing us with opportunities to meet, we still have several questions and concerns about the legislation.
Some of the major concerns that we have relate to the objectivity of the evaluations that are to be determined. We understand that for individuals who opt in to the performance based system 50% of their evaluation will be determined by student growth and the remaining 50% will be determined by criteria to be established by the State Board of Education.
Student Achievement
When examining student growth and using that as a factor in determining pay we would offer caution. We do not view competition as a bad thing but we do believe that it could certainly create a non collegial environment. We feel it is critical that the introduction of competition does not stifle cooperation and collaboration among educators.
Recent stories in several parts of the state suggest that there have been signs of tampering with tests. Some of these stories go on to state that if cheating is confirmed some of the schools may be forced to give back public money they won as prizes for stellar test scores. We know that this legislation does not encourage dishonesty however we want to make sure that proposals with potentially unintended consequences have been fully vetted and that the various stakeholder groups have had an opportunity to provide input and insight into their development.
Finally, as it relates to student achievement: if growth is such a large factor in the awarding of bonuses we may see some of our better classroom teachers abandon some of our higher performing schools to go to lower performing schools. While this is definitely a plus for the lower performing students, we could very well end up having long term subs and potentially unqualified individuals standing before some of Georgia's highest performing students thus compromising their continued success.
Evaluation
In these criteria we would like to know if classroom professionals' input will be sought. Will there be a time for public comment? We are really curious about the 'remaining 50% of the calculation being based on one or more factors as determined by the State Board of Education.' We understand that there is a reference to a peer review in the bill and we want to stress that this review is critical in helping professionals identify areas of improvement. (79% on survey)
Evaluations may affect performance. People tend to work harder if they are told they are doing a good job. People get demoralized if they are told they are doing poorly. How will the evaluation process take this into account?
Other Concerns
1. Page 6 locals to take into consideration the nature of duties to be performed, responsibility of the position held, subject matter or grades to be taught' Serious concerns about this portion of the bill.
2. Advanced degrees will not be rewarded in the new system.
3. Once a person elects to the performance based schedule they are forever tied to that system.
4. According to survey, teachers indicate that the current evaluation process accurately differentiates effective from ineffective teachers (close to 50%) of those surveyed.
5. The survey also indicates that teachers (40+%) feel that effective teachers are recognized and rewarded.
6. 86% of teachers would want their children taught by teachers within their schools a sign of collaboration.
In regard to this bill we respectfully ask the sponsors of this legislation to consider studying this issue so as not to create unintended consequences. We believe that by studying this issue and developing a new plan with multiple stakeholders' input we can create a reform that all individuals in the public schools can embrace.
I hope that the Committee will briefly indulge me. I want to assure you that GAE would never intentionally falsify any information to members of our organization or to members of this legislature. We value our credibility and for the past several years have made every effort to cease the anticipated 'No' and to offer alternatives. Our alternatives may vary ideologically from the majority but we are committed to being a part of the solution and not the problem.
Thank you.