Skip to content
Georgia Association of Educators
Georgia Association of Educators schoolhouse mark Georgia Association of Educators Support · Protect · Strengthen
Toll free in Georgia1 800 282 7142
Join GAE

Fall 2005 Vol. 4, Issue 1

Dekalb County Educator Exonerated From Criminal Warrant Alleging He Exposed Students to Inappropriate Computer Image

A Dekalb County teacher was away temporarily from his classroom. Students, presumably playing a prank, accessed an inappropriate sexual picture and left it on the laptop computer on the teacher's desk. However, a student's parent took out an Arrest Warrant against the teacher on alleged grounds he had shown inappropriate nude pictures on his computer to his class. The teacher was not aware that the picture was on his computer and was away from his class for a short period of time during which the picture was downloaded. GAE Network Attorneys represented the teacher. Upon hearing the warrant application, the State Court of DeKalb County ruled that there was insufficient evidence to prove that the teacher was aware of the picture on his computer or that he had shown the picture to anyone purposely. The Court found there was no intent of any kind by the teacher to cause harm or expose the students to inappropriate computer images.

In light of this case, GAE recommends that educators with school or personal computers used on school grounds always install passwords for access and turn off their computers when leaving them in the classroom or anywhere out of their sight on school property.

Clayton County Educator Has Arrest Warrant Dismissed

A veteran Clayton County teacher was served with an Arrest Warrant application taken out against the teacher by the parent for allegedly hitting a student in the arm. The student had been throwing pens and hit another student in the head and threw one pen under the teacher's desk. The student refused the teacher's directive to go to the administrative offices, and did not go until the Assistant Principal summoned the student. The student made no accusation of the teacher hitting him until two hours after the incident'and not on the first explanation. The GAE attorney showed the student's testimony to be unreliable, particularly in light of several independent witnesses that supported the teacher. The parent and the student testified, there were three student witnesses available for the teacher, and the Assistant Principal testified that their investigation and interviews of students did not support the student's story. The Magistrate Court of Clayton County found no probable cause and dismissed the warrant.

APS Teacher's Non renewal Reduced to 5 Day Suspension

A veteran 20 year teacher with the Atlanta Public Schools was non renewed by the Superintendent based on her new Principal's accusation that she had been inefficient, willfully neglected her duties, and was insubordinate. He also accused her of significant absences and tardiness. However, the Principal had only two years experience in the school and the evidence showed that he and the teacher had an ongoing personality conflict, which had culminated in one loud confrontation between them after which he recommended her non renewal. At the hearing, the GAE attorney presented evidence showing that the absences were earlier in the year for legitimate reasons, and there was no willful disregard of school policies. Most significant was evidence obtained by the GAE attorney on cross examination of the Principal, which exposed the Principal's difficult management style and personality. This cross examination testimony led the Tribunal to understand that the Principal had unfairly harassed the teacher and was largely to blame for the confrontation. As a result of its findings, the Tribunal decided the system had not proved cause to non renew the teacher. The Tribunal reduced the penalty to a 5 day suspension.

PSC Exonerates Hancock County Principal From CRCT Testing Violations

PSC charges were brought against a Hancock County Principal and GAE member for allegedly allowing long term substitutes to administer the CRCT tests. The Principal had employed at least five applicants of the Teacher Alternative Place Program (TAPP) in her school, a program that would allow non certified personnel to work in the classroom while acquiring certification. During the 2004 state wide testing period, five of the classrooms involved in the state wide tests were being taught by TAPP applicants.Because they were not certified instructors, they were not legally authorized to administer state tests. The Principal arranged for the scheduling of five certified instructors to do the administration part of the state wide tests in these classrooms containing non certified personnel. She and her staff informed the non certified personnel they were only to proctor the tests, not to administer them. GAE's Network Attorney separately investigated and got sworn affidavits supporting that the GAE member had followed the proper protocol. The PSC investigator tried to expand the investigation beyond its original scope of charges, without proper notice. Ultimately, the PSC was forced to conclude that no probable cause existed to sanction the Assistant Principal's certificate.

APS Board and Tribunal Reverse Superintendent's Recommendation of Teacher's Non Renewal

A 28 year veteran APS Middle School teacher was non renewed for receiving a does not meet expectations on his 2004 2005 annual evaluation. GAE's Network Attorneys represented him at an all day hearing. His 2003 2004 annual evaluation had been satisfactory. In the fall of 2004, the teacher received an unsatisfactory on his first 20 minute observation. Due to the results of this first observation and as required by APS evaluation policies, his evaluators placed him on the so called non tenure track procedures for evaluations. However, his evaluators did not inform him of the change in evaluation status as their internal policies required them to do. Under this evaluation track, he was entitled to 3 more 20 minute observations, but received only two observations. He also was never given an opportunity to remediate the deficiencies.Because APS violated its own internal procedures on evaluations, thereby limiting the teacher's right to actively participate in the process and to adequately address the recommendations and deficiencies cited, and because they failed to prove that he was ineffective as a teacher, the APS Board rejected the Superintendent's recommendation to non renew the teacher and he was reinstated to his employment.

PSC Reduces Educator's 1 Year Certificate Suspension to 1 Week Based on Evidence Introduced at Due Process Hearing

The PSC brought charges against an MOID* teacher in Cobb County for violating the Code of Ethics relating to handling public funds and property, misrepresentation and falsification, confidentiality, and unprofessional conduct. All the alleged violations were based on various fund raising activities, donations made for some of the students in her class and their respective families, and the activities of special education students at her school. The PSC investigated the Educator's efforts to raise funds for items needed for her class as well as her success at private fundraising for some students and their families. The PSC also inquired into the Educator's efforts to teach her MOID students how to function in the real world by opening a coffee shop run by her students inside the school.

Based on the PSC investigator's findings, the PSC made an initial probable cause determination and proposed a 1 year suspension of the Educator's certificate. The GAE Network Attorney appealed the proposed sanction and represented the Educator at the due process hearing before an Administrative Law Judge. Witness after witness testified about the Educator's dedication to her students and her extraordinary efforts to go above and beyond the call of duty to support their physical, mental, and emotional welfare.After reviewing the school's policies and procedures and the PSC Ethics Code, the Judge determined that the PSC had not met its burden with respect to showing a misuse or co mingling of any funds, any violation of federal confidentiality laws, or any unprofessional conduct. The Judge reduced the certificate sanction to only a warning. On agency review of the Judge's decision, the PSC determined that the educator violated the ethics standards regarding public funds and unprofessional conduct, but in light of the Judge's decision, modified the sanction to only a 1 week suspension. The Educator decided not to appeal.

* Moderate Intellectual Disability